Remotely Controlled Bathymetric Survey Craft Kordil RC

May 2010

Request a Quote for Kordil RC

Request a quote for a comparable remotely controlled survey system.

Request a Quote

Kordil's First Remotely Controlled Survey Craft Kordil RC Bathymetric Survey and Report

Content has been condensed

INTRODUCTION

The survey aimed to support safe navigation for vessels entering, leaving or potentially using the area around a jetty. Contact details for the party and organisation commissioning the bathymetric survey were provided below. Because the methods and systems used differed somewhat from routine bathymetric surveys, this document sets out the work in detail and as transparently as possible. It should therefore be assessed as a whole rather than in isolated sections. Throughout fieldwork and reporting, every effort was made to include the details required for approval by SHOD, the competent approving authority. 

EQUIPMENT DETAILS.

Bathymetric Survey Craft

Kordil RC is a remotely controlled surface survey craft used for depth measurement in nearshore and restricted-access areas. This archived field report describes its operation with a GNSS positioning and depth measurement system.

uzaktan-kumandali-bot.jpg

KROV KROV surveying confined areas using remote control and high manoeuvrability.

KROV carries the following equipment.

Topcon GRS-1 GNSS Receiver

Ohmex SonarM8/Mite Single-Beam Echo Sounder

Sony VAIO Computer

Inside KROV: the device beneath the pen is the Topcon GRS-1, with the Ohmex SonarM8 to its left and the Sony VAIO P Series computer at the far left.

uzaktan-kumandali-batimetri-araci.jpg

Rear view of KROV. The SonarM8 transducer can be seen at the lower centre.

Echo-Sounding System

Ohmex SonarMite/M8 is a digital echo sounder operating at 235 kHz and usable to depths of 75 m. Its intelligent transducer and bottom-tracking function output digital depths with a quality indicator over RS232 or Bluetooth. The original report describes the system as meeting IHO standards. 

Positioning

The Topcon GRS-1 is a mobile, precise GNSS positioning system using the L1 and L2 bands. It also supports DGPS using EGNOS and WAAS corrections. 

Sound Velocity

AML Oceanographic sound velocity instrument was used. 

Data Acquisition

A Sony VAIO P Series notebook on board the craft was used for data acquisition. Further technical details were not considered necessary.

SURVEY

Offsets

The vertical distances between the GPS antenna, water level and echo sounder transducer on KROV are shown in the illustration below.

uzaktan-kumandalı-bot.jpg

Survey Line Spacing

Survey lines were designed at 10 m spacing. Care was taken to avoid wider gaps wherever possible, and many areas were surveyed at a higher density.

Final points loaded into the PDS2000 DTM editor. The survey lines are also distinguishable. The cyan line marks the boundary.

Survey Method

The Topcon GRS-1 was used in DGPS mode throughout the survey. Raw GPS antenna data were recorded simultaneously at one-second intervals to compensate for possible interruptions. DGPS was preferred to CORS-TR because it provided more continuous data. On the final day of work (03/05/2011), the area previously occupied by a vessel in the harbour and several remaining gaps were surveyed using RTK with CORS-TR.

The raw data were also used to calculate the mean antenna elevation and hence the water level, assuming a constant antenna height above the water. To minimise local errors, data stability and quality were assessed and the best-quality records selected for the water-level calculation.

 Survey lines were followed using bearings taken from existing 10 m markings on the jetties and from the opposite jetties. Remaining gaps were subsequently filled by additional survey runs.

The incoming echo sounder and SonarMite data streams were recorded independently and simultaneously with timestamps at a resolution of 1/1000 second (milliseconds), for later processing. The simultaneous data Kordil Navigation Pro were acquired using the software.

Kordil Navigation Pro includes a terminal emulator that timestamps incoming serial-port data at millisecond resolution and records it at high speed. At the same time, it displays basic navigation information, including datum and Transverse Mercator coordinates or an unprojected view, survey lines, position and speed. Tracks already covered are marked, allowing omitted or uncovered areas to be identified when the craft is brought ashore.

The examples below show how SonarM8 and GPS data were recorded during the survey. These time-based records were subsequently processed with Kordil SonarMagic into a raw-data format.

SonarM8 Data Format

The colours in the explanations correspond to those in the data. These are actual records from the final survey day.

  • Date (YYYY-MM-DD)
  • Time (HHMMSSFFF)
  • Sensor Number
  • Depth Below Transducer
  • Battery Voltage
  • Data Quality Indicator
  • Empty

2011-03-05 153403582 1 10.47 12.8 102 0

2011-03-05 153404081 1 10.5 12.8 95 0

2011-03-05 153404565 1 10.5 12.8 102 0

2011-03-05 153405080 1 10.53 12.8 96 0

2011-03-05 153405579 1 10.54 12.8 98 0

2011-03-05 153406078 1 10.6 12.8 95 0

2011-03-05 153406577 1 10.65 12.8 98 0

2011-03-05 153407077 1 10.69 12.8 104 0

2011-03-05 153407576 1 10.66 12.8 102 0

2011-03-05 153408075 1 10.72 12.8 102 0

2011-03-05 153408574 1 10.74 12.8 105 0

2011-03-05 153409089 1 10.77 12.8 99 0

2011-03-05 153409573 1 10.77 12.8 103 0

2011-03-05 153410072 1 10.78 12.8 103 0

2011-03-05 153410587 1 10.78 12.8 95 0

2011-03-05 153411070 1 10.78 12.8 102 0

2011-03-05 153411585 1 10.8 12.8 99 0

2011-03-05 153412069 1 10.8 12.7 102 0

2011-03-05 153412568 1 10.8 12.8 98 0

2011-03-05 153413067 1 10.83 12.8 101 0

2011-03-05 153413582 1 10.9 12.8 100 0

NMEA GGA Message

The colours in the explanations correspond to those in the data.

Date (YYYY-MM-DD)

Time (HHMMSSFFF)

NMEA GGA Message

2011-03-05 153407092  $GPGGA,123346.00,4057.9422178,N,02840.6468273,E,4,10,1.26,-2.0301,M,39.4704,M,2.0,0206*55

2011-03-05 153408091 $GPGGA,123347.00,4057.9421113,N,02840.6468362,E,4,10,1.26,-2.0495,M,39.4704,M,2.0,0206*51

2011-03-05 153409105 $GPGGA,123348.00,4057.9420153,N,02840.6468614,E,4,10,1.46,-2.0429,M,39.4704,M,1.0,0206*5D

2011-03-05 153410103 $GPGGA,123349.00,4057.9419249,N,02840.6468750,E,4,10,1.46,-2.0645,M,39.4704,M,2.0,0206*54

2011-03-05 153411086 $GPGGA,123350.00,4057.9418444,N,02840.6468845,E,4,10,1.26,-2.0517,M,39.4704,M,1.0,0206*5C

2011-03-05 153412100 $GPGGA,123351.00,4057.9417594,N,02840.6469139,E,4,10,1.26,-2.0801,M,39.4704,M,1.0,0206*57

2011-03-05 153413129 $GPGGA,123352.00,4057.9416350,N,02840.6469365,E,4,10,1.61,-2.0037,M,39.4704,M,1.0,0206*5E

DATA PROCESSING

ABOUT THE DIGITAL DATA

The digital data in Appendix 2 are numbered in processing order and underwent the following steps.

GPS records without corrections were excluded; a minimum of five satellites and a 15-degree elevation mask were applied.

Depths were filtered using the SonarM8 quality indicator, retaining values of 50 or above. Consecutive readings were also examined individually; the entire dataset was reviewed against neighbouring readings, standard deviations and the overall trend to remove potentially faulty data. All depths were corrected using measured sound velocity in water. The sound velocity measured on the final day was 1484 m/s.

Depths were reduced to the TUTGA datum using water-level elevations.

Kordil SonarMagic processed the timestamped records using time as the common parameter to calculate the position at each depth observation.

After cleaning, the data were reduced to latitude, longitude and datum-reduced depth values.

Coordinates were transformed to the TM projection and retained for preparation of the final map.

Timestamped XYZ data were imported into PDS2000. Profiles were inspected and faulty data removed. The corrected profiles were then annotated at 10 m intervals using the PDS2000 plot module in accordance with SHOD requirements.

Profiles imported into PDS2000

SOFTWARE

The following software was used for data processing.

Kordil Geodesy Tools + SonarMagic: Coordinate and data-processing software based on the same sounding principles used by industry-standard applications. Primarily intended for echo sounders, it can also be used with other sensors. It calculates the position at the time an echo sounder or other instrument measurement is received, using time as the common parameter, and outputs the corresponding coordinates.

PDS2000: Hydrographic survey and processing software

Topcon Tools: GPS post-processing software

BEGIN: Kordil Kordil SonarMagic Processed Data

TIME,Lat,Lon,Height,GPSFix,Sensor_Raw_data,GPS_Closest_Raw_Data

153408075,4057.94211300571,2840.64683605746,-2.0398,FIX 4,Raw_Sensor_Begin->,2011-03-05 153408075 1 10.72 12.8 102 0,<-Raw_Sensor_End,Raw_GPS_Begin->,2011-03-05 153408091 $GPGGA,123347.00,4057.9421113,N,02840.6468362,E,4,10,1.26,-2.0495,M,39.4704,M,2.0,0206*51,<-Raw_GPS_End

153409089,4057.94201681479,2840.64686100237,-2.0462,FIX 4,Raw_Sensor_Begin->,2011-03-05 153409089 1 10.77 12.8 99 0,<-Raw_Sensor_End,Raw_GPS_Begin->,2011-03-05 153409105 $GPGGA,123348.00,4057.9420153,N,02840.6468614,E,4,10,1.46,-2.0429,M,39.4704,M,1.0,0206*5D,<-Raw_GPS_End

153410072,4057.94192770802,2840.64687457756,-2.0537,FIX 4,Raw_Sensor_Begin->,2011-03-05 153410072 1 10.78 12.8 103 0,<-Raw_Sensor_End,Raw_GPS_Begin->,2011-03-05 153410103 $GPGGA,123349.00,4057.9419249,N,02840.6468750,E,4,10,1.46,-2.0645,M,39.4704,M,2.0,0206*54,<-Raw_GPS_End

153411070,4057.94184571027,2840.64688434537,-2.0581,FIX 4,Raw_Sensor_Begin->,2011-03-05 153411070 1 10.78 12.8 102 0,<-Raw_Sensor_End,Raw_GPS_Begin->,2011-03-05 153411086 $GPGGA,123350.00,4057.9418444,N,02840.6468845,E,4,10,1.26,-2.0517,M,39.4704,M,1.0,0206*5C,<-Raw_GPS_End

153412069,4057.94176199862,2840.64691300118,-2.0659,FIX 4,Raw_Sensor_Begin->,2011-03-05 153412069 1 10.8 12.7 102 0,<-Raw_Sensor_End,Raw_GPS_Begin->,2011-03-05 153412100 $GPGGA,123351.00,4057.9417594,N,02840.6469139,E,4,10,1.26,-2.0801,M,39.4704,M,1.0,0206*57,<-Raw_GPS_End

153413067,4057.94164249543,2840.64693513829,-2.0419,FIX 4,Raw_Sensor_Begin->,2011-03-05 153413067 1 10.83 12.8 101 0,<-Raw_Sensor_End,Raw_GPS_Begin->,2011-03-05 153413129 $GPGGA,123352.00,4057.9416350,N,02840.6469365,E,4,10,1.61,-2.0037,M,39.4704,M,1.0,0206*5E,<-Raw_GPS_End

END: Kordil Kordil SonarMagic Processed Data

The red lines show coordinates calculated from GGA messages by linear interpolation to the time of each sonar reading. The nearest GGA message is retained on the same line for visual checks and gross-error detection. Depth readings without position data sufficiently close in time relative to the position update rate are excluded. To allow independent verification of the calculated coordinates, the nearest original GPS record at an appropriate interval is appended to each line. This provides a cross-check against the closest uninterpolated GPS observation for the same time period.

The timestamped records were combined in Kordil SonarMagic, and the required sound-velocity, offset and water-level corrections were applied in Excel.

The resulting XYZ data were further processed and edited in PDS2000 to produce the final map.

The following criteria were applied to the raw data:

All position records without DGPS or RTK corrections were excluded from processing.

Irregular depth readings and readings with a quality indicator below 50 were removed.

Neighbouring readings were checked using the deviation criterion stated in the original report as “0.20 cm”, with the subsequent explanation referring to 20 cm. Readings differing by more than 20 cm from the preceding or following observation were examined further and either rejected or retained for review with cross-lines on the plan.

Edited elevations were examined in profile and plan, together with contours. The resulting surface was reduced to a 5 m grid for the final map.

Final coordinates were checked again using 10 cm contours on the plan, and suspicious data without sufficient point density were removed.

The final, unsmoothed coordinates were loaded into the PDS2000 1 m × 1 m grid editor and inspected in three dimensions to identify potentially unrealistic features. No significant data requiring removal were found.

Three-dimensional views of the bathymetric data from different angles, with fivefold vertical exaggeration. The image shows a generally smooth surface. The same data without vertical exaggeration

Original survey points selected along the lines were also labelled with elevations in the bathymetric map, in accordance with the SHOD report format.

COORDINATE SYSTEM

Horizontal Reference Datum: WGS 84

CONTROL POINTS

The GNSS receiver data were processed using the nearest CORS-TR stations listed below. Station coordinates were taken from the headers of RINEX files downloaded from http://212.156.70.42/ using the account name “k*****”.

Station Cartesian Coordinates (Earth-Centred, Earth-Fixed: X, Y, Z)

KABR 4206855.6823 2301542.2908 4191502.3219

ISTN 4223661.0695 2325014.9869 4161716.1471

Station Coordinates Converted to Geographic Coordinates

Station name, latitude, longitude and ellipsoidal height are given below.

KABR 41o 20’  49.6262’’         28 o 40’ 57.9755’’ 93.613 m

ISTN 40 o 59’  27.4612’’         28 o 49’ 53.8823’’ 77.066 m

Vertical reference datum: GNSS antenna elevations were recorded throughout the survey, and hourly mean water-level elevations were calculated relative to the WGS 84 ellipsoid. Ellipsoidal heights were reduced to the map datum using geoid heights formally requested and obtained from the relevant authority at the General Command of Mapping. The calculated water levels were checked against water-level records from the nearest station, also supplied by that authority. Comparison with the Karaburun records gave reasonable differences and supported the calculated water levels.

All GPS antenna elevations were calculated with Topcon Tools post-processing software. The image below shows the adjusted points calculated for each epoch. Related calculation tables are provided in Appendix G.

Note: Half a day of RINEX data was missing on 23 March 2011. To cover this period, RINEX records from İSKİ's UKBS system were used in a free-network adjustment to solve the kinematic data. The relevant data were supplied electronically.

UNPROCESSED RAW DATA

The raw data are supplied electronically in the relevant appendix and comprise:

Daily GPS and echo sounder records acquired in real time

Simultaneously downloaded static CORS records and static data collected by the GNSS receiver on the craft.

SURVEY QUALITY CONTROL

The following checks were performed throughout surveying and processing to control measurement quality.

A cross-line perpendicular to the day's parallel survey lines was run. Nearby seabed observations were compared, and differences were found to be within reasonable limits.

On surveys carried out on different days, additional observations were made over previously covered areas. Intersecting lines were examined and nearby points checked for possible water-level or depth-reading errors. No unrealistic or unacceptable deviations were found.

Post-processed water levels reduced to the reference datum were compared with Karaburun Station data supplied by the General Command of Mapping; no significant differences were observed. Because Karaburun was about 70 km away, the locally measured and calculated water levels were considered more representative and used in the calculations.

For independent checking, the coordinates of the jetty bollard shown below were measured and recorded. Its location and coordinates are given below. This point was surveyed in RTK FIX mode using CORS-TR, averaging 200 epochs (200 seconds). The coordinate system is WGS 84.

Latitude: ** **’ **.***’’ N

Longitude: ** **’ **.***’’ E

Ellipsoidal Height: **.** m

Helmert Orthometric Height: 39.821 − 36.581 = 3.24 m (36.581 is the geoid undulation supplied by the General Command of Mapping).

PERSONNEL

All surveying and processing work was carried out with the following personnel.

HK (Geodesy and Photogrammetry Engineer), Yıldız Technical University, graduated in 1995

Following graduation, he worked in photogrammetry and geodetic surveying and, from 2001 onwards, at almost every level of hydrographic surveying on major marine projects for leading international companies. At the time of the report, he had nine years of active marine and subsea experience and had spent the preceding year undertaking various subsea surveys and investigations through Kordil. His CV is attached.

MS (Surveying and Cadastre Technician), Bursa Uludağ University, graduated in 2009

Has adequate knowledge and experience in land surveying, but no substantial hydrographic survey experience.

APPENDICES

APPENDIX A: Bathymetric Maps

APPENDIX B: Source Information

General Command of Mapping Geoid Height

Karaburun Station water-level data supplied by the General Command of Mapping for checking. Because winds during the survey were from north to south, Karaburun was preferred to Yalova despite being farther away. The records were obtained by email and included in Appendix

Technical specifications of instruments and systems

Topcon GRS-1 GNSS Receiver

Ohmex SonarM8/Mite Echo Sounder

AML SmartSVP Sound Velocity Profiler

APPENDIX Ç: Field Photographs and Videos

Field Photographs

Field Videos

APPENDIX D: Horizontal Control Point Records

No additional horizontal control point was used because CORS-TR Virtual RTK and EGNOS DGPS signals were used.

APPENDIX E: Vertical Control Point Records

No levelling benchmark was used. Instead, CORS-TR stations and the geoid height supplied by the General Command of Mapping were used. Raw GNSS data were post-processed to calculate the GPS antenna elevation, and water levels were derived using the antenna height above the water.

APPENDIX F: Levelling Records

Not applicable; this method was not used.

APPENDIX G: Staff Gauge / Digital Tide Gauge Installation Sketch

Not applicable; no staff gauge was used.

APPENDIX Ğ: Water-Level Records

Daily and hourly water levels and echo sounder transducer elevations reduced to the vertical datum.

APPENDIX H: Training Certificates

Diplomas and CVs

APPENDIX I: Signature Declarations

Copies are attached; originals were presented.

APPENDIX İ: Digital Data

KROV Raw Data File

Raw data cleaned using quality criteria

Raw data with sound-velocity corrections applied to depths

Cleaned depth data reduced to the TUDKA datum

Combined GNSS and Echo Sounder Raw Output

Geographic coordinates and elevations of surveyed points

Surveyed point coordinates in the TM (Gauss–Krüger) projection